The doctrine of merger in judgment

Produced in partnership with Jack Mitchell of Old Square Chambers
Practice notes

The doctrine of merger in judgment

Produced in partnership with Jack Mitchell of Old Square Chambers

Practice notes
imgtext

What is merger in judgment and its relationship with Res judicata?

A res judicata is a decision given by a judge or tribunal with jurisdiction over the cause of action and the parties, which disposes, with finality, of a matter decided so that it cannot be re-litigated by those bound by the judgment, except on appeal.

For further guidance, see Practice Note: The doctrine of res judicata.

Merger in judgment is a doctrine that treats a cause of action as extinguished once judgment has been given on it so that the claimant's sole right is a right on the judgment. It is a substantive rule about the legal effect of an English judgment, which is regarded as 'of a higher nature' so that the inferior remedy is merged in the higher and therefore supersedes the underlying cause of action (King v Hoare).

Autrefois acquit and autrefois convict enforce the doctrine of merger in judgment in the criminal law (Rogers v R (1994) 181 CLR 251 (at pp 256, 279) (not

Jack Mitchell
Jack Mitchell

Barrister, Old Square Chambers


Jack Mitchell specialises only in employment law and advises on the entire spectrum of claims, but is best known for work on whistleblowing and discrimination claims. He advises on the commercial aspects of employment, providing advice to both corporate and individual clients on a broad range of commercial matters including breach of contract claims, shareholder disputes and partnership issues.
He is regularly instructed in large complex claims in all areas of employment law, from Tribunals to High Court claims and appeals at all levels.
Jack has been elected to ELBA (Employment Law Bar Association) and has been appointed its Treasurer.
 
Other publications:
Whistleblowing: Law and Practice
Fourth Edition (2022), Third Edition (2017), Second (2012) and First (2007), with Jeremy Lewis KC, John Bowers KC and Martin Fodder.
Published by Oxford University Press (This should include an outline of the most important points of your career. It should not exceed 250 words in length.) 

Powered by Lexis+®
Jurisdiction(s):
United Kingdom
Key definition:
Res judicata definition
What does Res judicata mean?

Latin for the matter has been decided. At common law, once a court has made a decision, the matter cannot be re-opened once the time limit for appealing or the relevant limitation period has expired.

Popular documents