Home / Dispute Resolution / Claims and remedies / Corporate disputes

Legal News

High Court confirms refusal of permission for ClientEarth derivative action against Shell directors (ClientEarth v Shell plc)

Copyright © 2025 LexisNexis

Published on: 26 July 2023

Published by a LexisNexis Dispute Resolution expert

Table of contents

Evidential burden on claimants
Criteria to consider at prima facie stage
Strategy vs implementation
Subjective vs objective test
Relevance of expert evidence

Article summary

Dispute resolution analysis: The High Court on 24 July 2023 handed down judgment confirming its earlier decision to refuse climate-change activist ClientEarth’s application for permission to continue a derivative action on behalf of Shell plc seeking to challenge its directors’ response to the risks posed to Shell’s business by climate change. Rupert Lewis, head of banking litigation, Neil Blake, partner, James Palmer, partner, Silke Goldberg, partner, Rebecca Perlman, partner, Maura McIntosh, professional support consultant and Ceri Morgan, professional support consultant, Herbert Smith Freehills explore the decision.

Popular documents

Misrepresentation—damages as a remedy

Misrepresentation—damages as a remedyThis Practice Note considers when damages are available as a remedy for a misrepresentation claim with reference to the Misrepresentation Act 1967 (MA 1967).For consideration of when the courts will rescind a contract for misrepresentation and when parties can

Negligence—when is the duty of care breached?

Negligence—when is the duty of care breached?Having established that a duty of care exists (see Practice Note: Negligence—when does a duty of care arise?), it is then necessary to consider whether or not there has been a breach of that duty. This will depend on a number of factors outlined below and

Contract interpretation—entire agreement clauses

Contract interpretation—entire agreement clausesParties may often seek to specify that the entirety of their contractual relationship is governed by the written contract they have signed. This is what is known as an ‘entire agreement clause’. This Practice Note considers why they are used and some

Causation and remoteness in tort and negligence claims

Causation and remoteness in tort and negligence claimsThis Practice Note considers the requirement for causation as part of establishing a viable claim in tort, including in negligence claims. It considers the aspects of factual causation: including the ‘but for’ test, evidencing it and its limits,