Court of Appeal clarifies liability and sentencing for serious breaches of TPOs (R v Chamdal)
Planning analysis: In R v Chamdal, the Court of Appeal held that in relation to offences under section 210 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (TCPA 1990), courts may impose deterrent, means-related fines, treating the offence as strict liability with at least negligent culpability where owners fail to check tree preservation order (TPO) coverage and obtain consent. It upheld a £200,000 fine for causing or permitting the cutting down of at least 132 trees as proportionate, stressing that harm includes the scale and amenity/biodiversity impact of felling and that reliance on contractors or the absence of financial motive does not significantly mitigate.