Bar Council demands investigation into HMCTS evidence system failures
The Bar Council of England and Wales has called for an urgent investigation following a leaked Her Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) report revealing that an IT bug caused evidence to go missing or become corrupted over several years. The report, obtained by the BBC, revealed that the HMCTS failed to address an IT bug, resulting in evidence being lost, overwritten, or appearing missing in civil, family, and tribunal court proceedings. Sources within the HMCTS indicated that judicial decisions may have been made based on incomplete evidence. The report further disclosed that HMCTS had not conducted a comprehensive investigation into the extent of the data corruption and had withheld information from judges and legal professionals, citing concerns that disclosure might cause more harm than good. In response, the Chair of the Council, Barbara Mills KC, emphasised that the potential miscarriages of justice merit an immediate investigation, particularly regarding emergency child protection cases and urged the Ministry of Justice to audit all court IT systems to ensure that they are fit for purpose.