Damages and exclusions

Due to the nature of construction projects, it is common for parties to raise claims relating to breaches of contract or negligence. As a result, the question of damages for these types of breaches, and how to minimise liability if faced with a claim, is extremely important.

Damages

The normal function of damages for breach of contract or negligence is compensatory—ie the aim is to compensate the innocent party for its true loss and place it in the same position, so far as money can do so, as it would have been in had the contract been performed or, in tort, as if the wrong not been suffered. Notwithstanding this difference in the contractual and tortious measures of damages, in many cases, the same result will follow from the application of either measure.

Practice Note Quantum in construction claims highlights some of the key considerations that parties to construction contracts should consider when formulating the quantum aspects of a claim for damages—including issues of causation and remoteness, the use of global claims, mitigation and betterment, contributory negligence, contractual restrictions or exclusions and supporting quantum

To view the latest version of this document and thousands of others like it, sign-in with LexisNexis or register for a free trial.

TAKE A FREE TRIAL

Latest Construction News

PINS updates pre-application prospectus for NSIPs with mandatory land tracker

The Planning Inspectorate (PINS) has updated its 2024 Pre-application Prospectus for nationally significant infrastructure projects (NSIP) by introducing a mandatory land and rights negotiations tracker as a primary service feature, releasing a new programme document template for use from 1 November 2025, and adding a section clarifying expectations for applicants engaging with the Inspectorate. These changes aim to improve application preparedness, streamline interactions, and support more efficient post-submission processes. Minor stylistic revisions were also made to enhance clarity and consistency throughout the document.

Construction weekly highlights—23 October 2025

This week's edition of Construction weekly highlights includes a Technology and Construction Court (TCC) decision in relation to damages under the Defective Premises Act 1972 (DPA 1972) and the ‘fit for habitation’ standard (Mallas v Persimmon Homes), the Building Safety Regulator (BSR)’s quarterly update on Gateway 2 building control approval applications; a TCC decision where the court refused enforcement of an adjudicator's decision on the basis that the claimant had made a false statement regarding a conflict of interest in its application for the appointment of an adjudicator (RNJM v Purpose Social Homes), guidance from the Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE) warning of risks linked to AI use, an analysis of AI’s transformative role in international construction projects and related legal risks, a report from Madrid International Arbitration Center – Ibero-American Arbitration Center (CIAM-CIAR) Working Group on International Arbitration on Expert Determination, a TCC ruling upholding an automatic suspension in a procurement dispute (Involve v DWP), the Scottish Government’s consultation on the proposed revised financial thresholds under the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014, a call from the Construction Leadership Council (CLC)’s Material Supply Chain Group for government stimulus amid construction market decline and publication of the August 2025 construction output by the Office for National Statistics (ONS).

CIAM-CIAR publishes its seventh report on Expert Determination in ADR disputes

The Madrid International Arbitration Center – Ibero-American Arbitration Center (CIAM-CIAR) Working Group on International Arbitration published its seventh report titled Expert Determination. This document explores Expert Determination (ED) as a binding alternative dispute resolution method, particularly suited to technical and commercial disputes. It outlines the procedural framework, including the contractual basis, expert appointment, and the role of nominating entities. ED is distinguished by its speed, cost-efficiency, confidentiality, and reliance on subject-matter expertise, with the expert’s decision being final and enforceable by prior agreement of the parties.

FMB publishes updated developers' guide addressing planning and regulatory changes

The Federation of Master Builders (FMB) has published an updated Developers' Guide covering recent regulatory changes including the National Planning Framework 4 for Scotland, the Future Homes Standard from 2026 and the Building Safety Regulator's transition to registered building control approvers. The guide addresses Biodiversity Net Gain exemptions for small sites and references the forthcoming National Housing Bank and National Housing Delivery Fund from 2026. The update aims to help small and medium-sized builders navigate planning, finance and regulatory barriers, with FMB research showing over 50% cite planning as the primary obstacle to housebuilding.