Supreme Court decides that NHS Trust should have charged VAT on the provision of car parking at hospitals (Northumbria Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust v HMRC)
Tax analysis: The Supreme Court unanimously allowed HMRC’s appeal, ruling that Northumbria Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust was not acting under a ‘special legal regime’ (SLR) when operating its hospital car parks and was therefore required to charge VAT. The Court clarified that external guidance, combined with the general public law obligation to adhere to it in the absence of good reason, was insufficient to amount to an SLR. As well as summarising the decision, this News Analysis contains commentary from Bryn Reynolds, Partner at Pinsent Masons LLP, on the implications of the judgment.