FTT rules that the taxpayer’s supplies of nurses and care assistants in direct competition with commercial enterprises were not exempt from VAT (1st Alternative Medical Staffing Ltd v HMRC)
Tax analysis: In 1st Alternative Medical Staffing Ltd v HMRC, the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) decided that the company’s supplies of nurses and care assistants did not qualify for exemption under Item 4, Group 7, Schedule 9 Pt II to the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (VATA 1994). The company was not a state regulated institution, but even if it had been, the FTT found that there was no statutory basis for exempting its supplies of staff. The Court of Appeal had previously decided that the company could not apply the extra-statutory concession for nursing agencies retrospectively (see R (oao First Alternative Medical Staffing Ltd and another) v HMRC).