Building safety; statutory construction; retrospectivity; exercise of discretion by FTT; meaning of ‘just and equitable’ (Triathlon Homes LLP v Stratford Village Development Partnership & Others)
Property Disputes analysis: The appeal in Triathlon Homes v Stratford Village Development Partnership & Others was heard together with Adriatic Land 5 Ltd v Leaseholders of Hippersley Point by the Court of Appeal in March 2025. Common to both appeals was the question of the retrospective operation of key provisions in the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA 2022). In Triathlon, Lord Justices Newey, Nugee and Holgate unanimously dismissed the appeal by Stratford Village Development Partnership and Get Living Plc against five remediation contribution orders (RCOs) made by the FTT totalling c. £16m under BSA 2022, s 124. The court rejected the appellants’ wide ranging and detailed attack on the FTT’s application of the ‘just and equitable’ test contained in BSA 2022, s 124 and held that RCOs can be made in respect of sums incurred before the BSA came into force in June 2022. Written by Camilla Chorfi, barrister at Falcon Chambers, who acted for the intervening Secretary of State.