Determinations

Determinations

A revenue determination in respect of direct tax:

•
is issued by HMRC where a taxpayer fails to file a tax return
•
is based on an HMRC estimate of the amount of tax due
•
is treated as though it were a tax return filed by the taxpayer, ie HMRC's estimate is the amount the taxpayer is liable to pay to HMRC, and
•
gives HMRC the opportunity to commence formal proceedings to recover the unpaid tax

There is no right of appeal against a direct tax revenue determination. As noted in Practice Note: What is a revenue determination for direct tax purposes?—How can a revenue determination be displaced?,

To view the latest version of this document and thousands of others like it, sign-in with LexisNexis or register for a free trial.

TAKE A FREE TRIAL

Latest Tax News

Dissenting shareholders and share buybacks for the benefit of a company’s trade

Private Client analysis: This case addresses whether a company’s purchase of shares from a majority shareholder qualified for capital gains tax treatment under section 1033 of the Corporation Tax Act 2010 (CTA 2010). The First-tier Tribunal allowed the taxpayer’s appeal, finding that the share buyback was ‘wholly or mainly for the purpose of benefiting’ the company’s trade, despite HMRC’s attempt to treat it as a distribution. The Tribunal took a pragmatic approach, considering the share purchase as part of a broader exit arrangement that would benefit the trade by resolving management disputes and enabling necessary business investments. Importantly, the Tribunal clarified that the company’s purpose, not the shareholder’s motives, is key when applying s 1033, and that the trade benefit can be achieved through the purchase in conjunction with other actions. The case offers valuable guidance on share buybacks, particularly where management disputes impede business development. Practical implications written by Rory Mullan KC of 15 Old Square Chambers.

FTT grants unconditional stay of proceedings to HMRC pending Court of Appeal decision and refuses repayment of VAT sums deposited (Uber London Ltd v HMRC)

Tax analysis: In Uber London Ltd v HMRC, the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) granted HMRC an unconditional stay in proceedings regarding the VAT treatment of private hire transport services supplied by Uber London Ltd (Uber) pending the final determination of an appeal involving another party. The FTT was not persuaded that the stay in proceedings must be conditional on the repayment to Uber of the amount it had deposited with HMRC.

UT agrees with FTT that former employee received earnings when ‘stock appreciation rights’ were realised and not when they were awarded (Saunders v HMRC)

Tax analysis: In Saunders v HMRC, the Upper Tribunal (UT) dismissed a non-UK resident taxpayer’s appeal against the First-tier Tax Tribunal’s (FTT) decision that a £1.2m payment he received from his former employer on the realisation of ‘stock appreciation rights’ (SARs) awarded to him in respect of his UK employment were taxable earnings that were not excluded from charge by split-year treatment.

FTT finds that importer who was not the owner of the goods could not claim credit for import VAT as input tax (TSI Instruments v HMRC)

Tax analysis: In TSI Instruments v HMRC, the First-tier Tax Tribunal (FTT) denied recovery of import VAT as input tax, holding that only the owner of the goods is entitled to recovery.