The need to show an undisputed or at least undisputable debt in winding up proceedings (McGann v Eldonian Community Trust Ltd)
Restructuring & Insolvency analysis: This case concerns a disputed winding‑up petition brought by Mr Anthony McGann against Eldonian Community Trust Ltd (Eldonian), a company limited by guarantee in Liverpool. McGann claimed to be a creditor for £18,755, which he alleged related to personal payments he made to lawyers and accountants on Eldonian’s behalf. He argued Eldonian had authorised him to make such payments and to be reimbursed. Eldonian opposed the petition, disputing both liability and McGann’s standing as a creditor. Key issues included: the authenticity of a retrospectively altered invoice, alleged invalid appointment of directors and trustees at the relevant time, whether the services were provided for Eldonian rather than another entity, and a purported cross‑claim alleging McGann acted as a de facto or shadow director. The court held there was a bona fide dispute on substantial grounds as to the alleged debt, meaning McGann lacked standing to petition. The winding‑up petition was therefore dismissed. Written by Alex Akin, associate at Keidan Harrison LLP.