Amending objects of a Royal Charter charity (Governors of the Free Grammar School of John Lyon v Attorney General)
Private Client analysis: This case examined how the charitable objects of Harrow School and The John Lyon School could be amended in principle. The court held that the schools' objects continued to be those that were set out in the 1572 Royal Charter by which Harrow School was established, despite the undertaking of the original corporation having been transferred to another body in the 19th century. Consequently, any amendments to the objects could only be made by the court (or the Charity Commission) giving effect to a scheme under section 68 of the Charities Act 2011 (ChA 2011) or by the charity exercising the statutory power of amendment set out in ChA 2011, s 280C, in both cases subject to approval by Order in Council. The court also found that ChA 2011, s 75ZA does not enable the court (or the Charity Commission) to make a scheme inconsistent with a Royal Charter or statute. This reaffirmed the ‘higher authority principle’ confirming that the scheme-making jurisdiction of the court cannot override a Royal Charter or statute but may only supplement it. Written by Andrew Mackie, managing associate at Foot Anstey LLP.