FTT refuses HMRC permission to appeal against case management decisions requiring explanation of £96m PAYE determinations (BGC Services Holdings LLP v HMRC)
Tax analysis: In BGC Services Holdings LLP v HMRC, the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) refused HMRC permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal (UT) against two case management decisions (i) refusing HMRC’s request for further and better particulars from the taxpayer, and (ii) requiring HMRC to particularise in its statement of case how salaried members rules conditions were met for which partners, how the determinations of over £96m were calculated, and the basis for alleging deliberate or careless behaviour on the part of the taxpayer. HMRC now has the right to appeal directly to the UT for permission to appeal the decisions.