Pear Pressure—joint tortfeasorship for company secretaries clarified (Wang Zeng v Bing Bing)
IP analysis: This case concerns competing fruiterers, and two exotic varieties of pears trade marked ‘Mountain Pear’ and ‘Yu Lu Frangrant Pear’. The Intellectual Property Enterprise Court found in favour of the trade mark proprietor, Wang Zeng International Ltd (WZI), against Bing Bing Foods Ltd and its sole director Mr Bingtao Wang, who admitted using identical marks for identical goods without consent. The defendants claimed that the marks were merely descriptive pear variety names and should be declared invalid. The court dismissed the defendants' wide-ranging but lightly-argued invalidity counterclaims under sections 3(1)(b), (c), and (d), section 46(1)(c), and section 3(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 (TMA 1994), finding that the marks were validly registered. The claimant was entitled to a declaration of infringement and injunctive relief against Bing Bing and Mr Bingtao Wang, who was found jointly liable, while the claim against the company secretary Mr Sohi was dismissed. Written by Sam Fisher, associate at CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP.