Case tracker—judgments handed down in 2015—pensions [Archived]
Case tracker—judgments handed down in 2015—pensions [Archived]

The following Pensions guidance note provides comprehensive and up to date legal information covering:

  • Case tracker—judgments handed down in 2015—pensions [Archived]
  • Alexander and others as Trustees of the Scottish Solicitors Staff Pension Fund v Pattison and Sim
  • Capita (Banstead 2011) Limited v RFIB Group
  • R (on the application of Fleet Maritime Services (Bermuda) Limited) v The Pensions Regulator
  • J&A Young (Leicester) Ltd v HMRC
  • Ascham Homes v Auguste
  • Re BCA Pension Plan
  • Ministry of Justice v O'Brien, Miller & two others (Court of Appeal)
  • Dutton v FDR
  • Donkor v The Royal Bank of Scotland
  • more

This case tracker lists pensions judgments handed down in 2015 chronologically, with the most recent case listed at the top, and provides.

  1. the case name and reference number

  2. a summary of the decision and key points

  3. details of the parties' legal representation

  4. the court and judgment date, and

  5. the citation and link to a transcript of the judgment

For judgments handed down in 2016 and 2013–2014, see:

  1. Case tracker—judgments handed down in 2016—pensions [Archived]

  2. Case tracker—judgments handed down in 2013–2014—pensions [Archived]

For forthcoming cases see: Case tracker—forthcoming cases.

Alexander and others as Trustees of the Scottish Solicitors Staff Pension Fund v Pattison and Sim

Case Name and Reference Number Decision Representation Court and Judgment Date Citation
Alexander and others as Trustees of the Scottish Solicitors Staff Pension Fund v Pattison and Sim

CA63/13
The case concerned a pension scheme that provides pensions for employees of solicitors' firms and their dependants in Scotland, and the dispute was over amendments to the scheme's trust deed and rules.

Until 1991, under the scheme rules, the amendment formalities included a 'triple-lock' procedure, which required two-thirds majority approval at