This immigration analysis considers the House of Lords Justice and Home Affairs Committee report, Settlement, Citizenship and Integration, following its inquiry into the government’s proposed reforms to indefinite leave to remain (ILR), citizenship and integration policy. The report focuses on what happens after entry: the route to permanent settlement through ILR or citizenship, including the proposed ‘earned settlement’ scheme. The proposals include extending the baseline qualifying period for settlement from five to ten years, longer routes for lower paid workers and refugees, and the retrospective application of the new rules to those already in the UK. The Committee’s majority is critical of those elements, concluding that longer routes would undermine integration and increase poverty, while retrospective change would be manifestly unfair and damage the UK’s attractiveness to migrants whose skills the UK wishes to retain. The report nevertheless accepts the principle that settlement may be ‘earned’ through requirements relating to conduct, language, work and contribution, provided the scheme is fair, evidence-based and supported by an integration strategy.