Scheme closure

Scheme closure

An increasing number of companies have closed their defined benefit (DB) occupational pension scheme to the accrual of future benefits and opened up a new defined contribution (DC) scheme instead for future service benefits.

Closing a scheme to future accrual of benefits is often not straightforward, and sponsoring employers and trustees will need to take into account a number of considerations before proceeding.

Where a closure proposal requires trustee consent, the trustees will need to be convinced that the employer has a good business case for closure before agreeing to the proposal. Employers should be prepared to provide evidence of their business case and to explain the financial and business impact for them if the scheme is not closed. The employer may also need to explain whether it considered any other options for reducing the costs and risks of the scheme falling short of full closure and, if so, why it discounted them.

Trustees may also look to obtain some advantage for members in return for agreeing to closure such as additional funding or security for the scheme.

Employer considerations

The main considerations for a sponsoring employer

To view the latest version of this document and thousands of others like it, sign-in with LexisNexis or register for a free trial.

TAKE A FREE TRIAL

Latest Pensions News

HMRC outlines new pension scheme regulations for public service remedy

HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) has detailed the Public Service Pension Schemes (Rectification of Unlawful Discrimination) (Tax) Regulations 2025, which came into force on 24 April 2025. The regulations establish joint liability between scheme administrators and members for unauthorised payments charges, extend the deadline for fixed/individual protection 2016 applications to 6 April 2027 for members with remediable service, and modify the treatment of top-up payments of defined benefits lump sum death benefits from 6 April 2024. The regulations also introduce new reporting requirements for scheme administrators and revise split schemes administration responsibilities. These changes complement previous regulations implemented in 2023.

PensionsEurope warns US Senate about pension fund tax changes in new Bill

PensionsEurope sent a letter to the US Senate on 16 June 2025 expressing concerns about section 899 of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. This follows the approval of the Bill by the US House of Representatives on 22 May 2025. This section, which will be added to the US Internal Revenue Code, aims to raise net income and withholding tax rates on US-source income earned by non-US individuals classified as ‘applicable persons’—a group that includes pension funds. As this change poses significant risks to European pension funds’ investments in the US, and with the US Senate scheduled to vote on the Bill on 23 June 2025, PensionsEurope is actively collaborating with the World Pension Alliance and other workplace pension organisations to address the issue.

Survey finds over one million gig workers ‘can’t afford’ to save for a pension

Law360: More than a million 'gig' workers in the UK cannot afford to save into a pension, a retirement savings company has said, amid growing fears that younger and more precarious workers will not have adequate savings in later life.

DWP announces appointment of Deborah Evans as new chair of TPO

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has announced the appointment of Deborah Evans as the new chair of The Pensions Ombudsman (TPO), effective from 1 July 2025, for a five-year term. Evans, who currently serves as a non-executive director and chair of TPO’s compliance committee, will take over from Anthony Arter, who has been interim chair since January 2024. The appointment was made by the Secretary of State following an open competition regulated by the Office for the Commissioner of Public Appointments. As chair, Evans will receive £24,000 per year for a minimum time commitment of 36 days annually. The announcement comes as the government’s Pension Schemes Bill continues its passage through Parliament, with proposed measures to strengthen the legal standing of TPO and improve the resolution of pension overpayment cases.