Totes of trouble—the battle over the Notting Hill shopping bag (Courtenay-Smith v Notting Hill Shopping Bag Co)
IP analysis: In a clash over creativity and commercial rights, Courtenay-Smith and The Notting Hill Bag Company Ltd took two brothers and their businesses to court, alleging trade mark infringement, passing off, and copyright infringement related to a tote bag design originally created and sold by Courtenay-Smith back in 2009. But the case took an unexpected turn. The court found that when Courtenay-Smith’s original company was dissolved in 2018, the rights to the trade mark and any attached goodwill didn’t stay with her—they passed to the Crown as bona vacantia (ownerless property). No valid steps had been taken to reclaim those rights, making the later trade mark renewal legally void. Without a valid trade mark or demonstrable goodwill, and with the court also finding no copyright infringement due to differences in design, the claimants’ case unravelled. The court’s dismissal of all claims serves as a clear reminder that inadequate management of IP during and after a company’s dissolution can leave valuable creative and commercial assets beyond recovery and outside the scope of legal protection. Written by Laura Evans, trainee trade mark attorney and Lee Curtis, partner and chartered trade mark attorney at HGF Limited, Manchester.