Judicial and environmental review

Environmental civil litigation arises in both public and private law. In general terms public environmental challenges arise by way of judicial review, statutory review and more recently environmental review, while private law claims most often arise in tort and include nuisance and negligence.

Judicial review and statutory review of environmental decisions

The starting-point in judicial review and statutory challenges is that the claimant must identify a legal error, as opposed to simply disagreeing with the decision-maker’s conclusion.

The general grounds of challenge in judicial review cases are set out in Practice Note: Judicial review—what it is and when it can be used. Some of the common grounds in environmental claims include:

•
challenging the way in which a decision was made
•
misinterpretation of environmental policy
•
challenging decisions involving environmental impact assessment (EIA) and habitats regulations and
•
challenging land use planning decisions

Judicial review does not generally extend to include a review of the merits of a decision but only the lawfulness of the way in which it was made. Consequently, any challenges that seek to allege that the substance

To view the latest version of this document and thousands of others like it, sign-in with LexisNexis or register for a free trial.

TAKE A FREE TRIAL

Latest Environment News

OEP submits evidence to EAC on PFAS regulation

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has submitted evidence to the Environmental Audit Committee (EAC)'s inquiry into per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). The submission identifies several regulatory gaps, including the absence of statutory limits and targets, limited data accessibility, inadequate monitoring systems for chemicals of concern and delays in regulatory decision-making. The OEP recommends: (1) adopting a coordinated approach to PFAS across its life cycle; (2) addressing monitoring gaps for new and emerging substances of concern; (3) incorporating the precautionary principle into policy and regulatory framework development; and (4) establishing clear governmental direction on PFAS use and pollution through the Environmental Improvement Plan Review and the UK Chemicals Strategy.

OEP responds to Defra's consultation on BNG reforms

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has responded to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs' consultation on biodiversity net gain (BNG) implementation reforms, expressing concerns about several proposed changes, particularly the plan to exempt minor developments, warning that this could narrow the scope of BNG and potentially lead to habitat loss. In its response letter, the OEP acknowledged Defra's overall aim of improving BNG implementation but advised that the reforms should be approached with caution, given BNG's early stage of operation. It recommended that any changes support broader nature improvement strategies, align with the upcoming revision of the Environmental Improvement Plan, and strengthen the likelihood of achieving legally binding nature targets. Additionally, the Chair of the OEP, Dame Glenys Stacey, highlighted the consultation's lack of detailed evidence regarding implementation challenges and the absence of impact assessments for the proposed reforms.

Environmental Agency publishes planning recommendations for sustainable development in English industrial clusters

The Environment Agency (EA) has published a report, outlining key recommendations for planning reforms aimed at supporting sustainable growth in England's industrial clusters, with a focus on the Humber, Teesside and HyNet (North West) regions. The report stresses the need for industrial clusters to be better recognised in future planning reforms. It further recommends that industrial clusters be proactively incorporated into local growth plans and developed with the necessary environmental infrastructure, such as an adequate water supply. The report also identifies significant challenges facing these clusters, including limited water resource availability and climate-related risks. To address these challenges, the EA proposes the implementation of strategic growth plans and cluster-scale planning tools. Additionally, the EA has published an associated collection of technical documents examining the environmental capacity for deploying carbon capture and hydrogen production technology within these clusters. This collection includes detailed evidence reviews covering water availability, air quality, flood risk assessments, and potential environmental impacts.