The Scottish Law Commission (SLC) has published its report on the Tenancy of Shops (Scotland) Act 1949 (TOS(S)A 1949), which applies when certain commercial leases expire, specifically for premises used in retail, hospitality, beauty services, wholesale units, and warehouses (shop leases) and grants tenants a limited right to seek lease renewal. TOS(S)A 1949 has been criticised for being outdated and not reflecting changes in Scotland's commercial property market. Additionally, there is ambiguity about whether certain non-retail premises qualify as ‘shop leases’ under TOS(S)A 1949. After evaluating four potential options: retention, reform, replacement with a mandatory notice to quit scheme, or complete repeal, the SLC concluded that repealing TOS(S)A 1949 without reform or statutory replacement is the most viable option, as it no longer serves its purpose and occasionally distorts lease negotiations in favour of large businesses. The SLC contends that future issues can be addressed through bespoke legislation that would cover leases to all businesses.