Section 45(1) of Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 (LRHUDA 1993) places an obligation on a landlord who is served with a section 42 request for a new lease to serve a counternotice by the date specified in the notice. The landlord can, in their counternotice, either admit the claim but dispute the terms proposed by the tenant, admit the claim and the proposed terms, deny the claim, or raise an intention to redevelop. If the landlord fails to serve a counternotice at all then, so long as they are entitled to a new lease, the tenant will become entitled to the same on the terms proposed in the section 42 notice. The court has no discretion in this regard. Once a section 42 notice is given, the tenant serving it becomes liable to pay the reasonable