Carl Fain#1453

Carl Fain

Property and chancery practice with a focus on landlord and tenant. Work includes all aspects of commercial and residential landlord and tenant including dilapidations claims, business tenancy renewals, enfranchisement, rights of first refusal, RTM, appointment of managers and service charge disputes.

Real property disputes including mortgage related claims and in particular LPA receivers, property related professional negligence, co-ownership, easements, nuisance, restrictive covenants, boundary disputes and Party Wall Act matters.

As well as appearing frequently in the County Court and the High Court, Carl has represented clients in the First-Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) and the Court of Appeal.

"Very bright, gets on well with clients and is a terrier in court" and "he's extremely knowledgeable, doesn't balk at any points and is ready with the answers." Chambers UK Bar Guide 2018 (Real Estate Litigation)

"A hidden treasure; he is very bright, good in court and with clients, and always goes the long mile without being asked."

Legal 500 2017 (Property Litigation)

Contributed to

131

A tenant has a lease of premises, has paid all rent under the lease until its expiry, is not in breach of
A tenant has a lease of premises, has paid all rent under the lease until its expiry, is not in breach of
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a tenant is entitled to be reimbursed for rent paid in advance.

A tenant has been in occupation of unregistered land outside of their demise. Assuming that this
A tenant has been in occupation of unregistered land outside of their demise. Assuming that this
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether it should be the occupying tenant or the landlord who makes the application for registration of an unregistered land currently outside of their demise.

A tenant is in occupation and holding over on a lease which expired in 2015 and was not contracted out of
A tenant is in occupation and holding over on a lease which expired in 2015 and was not contracted out of
Q&A

This Q&A looks at whether the grant of a renewal lease will automatically end a previous lease between the same landlord and tenant.

A Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 tenant wishes to surrender their lease. Can the lease be surrendered
A Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 tenant wishes to surrender their lease. Can the lease be surrendered
Q&A

This Q&A considers if an LTA (1954 protected lease can be surrendered without the landlord needing to serve a section 25 notice

Absent an express right to do so, where a property owner (A) needs access to a neighbour’s (B) land to
Absent an express right to do so, where a property owner (A) needs access to a neighbour’s (B) land to
Q&A

This Q&A considers how to replace a pipe on a neighbour’s land where there is no express right to do so.

An owner of dominant land has used a right of way over servient land for over 20 years. The servient land
An owner of dominant land has used a right of way over servient land for over 20 years. The servient land
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a freeholder of servient land can defend a claim for a prescriptive easement on the basis that they have never been in a position to object to the use.

An underlease rent review provision refers to review of the rent as per the superior lease. If the
An underlease rent review provision refers to review of the rent as per the superior lease. If the
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether an underlease will be invalidated if a superior lease has been surrendered.

Are easements extinguished by unity of seisin where the servient tenement and part only of the dominant
Are easements extinguished by unity of seisin where the servient tenement and part only of the dominant
Q&A

This Q&A considers the effect of the principle of unity of seisin in relation to easements.

Are there any restrictions, requirements or other provisions with regards to the type of company that the
Are there any restrictions, requirements or other provisions with regards to the type of company that the
Q&A

This Q&A considers the restrictions, requirements and other provisions with regards to the type of company that the tenants can incorporate to exercise a right of first refusal pursuant to Part I of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.

Can a deed of surrender be conditional on obligations that extend beyond the date on which the deed of
Can a deed of surrender be conditional on obligations that extend beyond the date on which the deed of
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a deed of surrender can be conditional on obligations that extend beyond the date on which the deed of surrender will be completed.

Can a landlord issue a section 21 notice if a gas safety certificate was not provided at the start of an
Can a landlord issue a section 21 notice if a gas safety certificate was not provided at the start of an
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a failure to provide a gas safety certificate at the start of an AST can be cured by granting a new fixed term and providing a certificate at that stage.

Can a landlord oppose the grant of a renewal lease under section 30 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
Can a landlord oppose the grant of a renewal lease under section 30 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a landlord is able to oppose the grant of a lease renewal with regard to section 30 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954.

Can a landlord serve a section 21 notice if there is no carbon monoxide alarm in the property?
Can a landlord serve a section 21 notice if there is no carbon monoxide alarm in the property?
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a landlord can serve a notice under HA 1988, s 21 if there is no carbon monoxide alarm in the property.

Can a lease which has been contracted out of the security of tenure provisions of the Landlord and Tenant
Can a lease which has been contracted out of the security of tenure provisions of the Landlord and Tenant
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a 'contracted out' lease can be amended with a deed of variation and whether it is necessary to follow the statutory contracting out process.

Can a letter agreeing to extend the statutory deadline pursuant to section 29B(1) of the Landlord and
Can a letter agreeing to extend the statutory deadline pursuant to section 29B(1) of the Landlord and
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a letter agreeing to extend the statutory deadline pursuant to section 29B(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 can be signed by one agent acting on behalf of two joint landlords.

Can a notice be served under section 42 of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993
Can a notice be served under section 42 of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993
Q&A

This Q&A looks at whether a property which is a free-standing house, but is described in the lease as a flat, qualifies for a lease extension under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993.

Can a section 42 notice under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 be deemed
Can a section 42 notice under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 be deemed
Q&A

This Q&A looks at whether a section 42 notice seeking a lease extension under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 will be invalidated by a failure to specify a date for service of a counter-notice at least two months after service of the notice.

Can a tenant who believed a garage was part of their demise and used it as such for over 30 years claim
Can a tenant who believed a garage was part of their demise and used it as such for over 30 years claim
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a tenant who believed a garage was part of their demise and used it as such for over 30 years can claim adverse possession after finding out subsequently they have no right to it under the lease.

Can surrender by operation of law be effected where the tenant has returned the keys and stated the lease
Can surrender by operation of law be effected where the tenant has returned the keys and stated the lease
Q&A

This Q&A looks at whether there can be an implied surrender where the tenant has returned the keys to the landlord, but has not otherwise communicated with the landlord.

Can the landlord of an assured shorthold tenancy obtain an order requiring the tenants to temporarily
Can the landlord of an assured shorthold tenancy obtain an order requiring the tenants to temporarily
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a landlord, who has been served with an improvement notice under section 11 of the Housing Act 2004, can obtain an order requiring tenants to temporarily vacate the property to carry out remedial works.

Practice Areas

Panel

  • Q&A Panel

Qualified Year

  • 2001

Membership

  • Property Bar Association
  • Chancery Bar Association

Education

  • MA (Oxon), The Queens College, Oxford

If you expected to see yourself on this page, click here.