Carl Fain#1453

Carl Fain

Property and chancery practice with a focus on landlord and tenant. Work includes all aspects of commercial and residential landlord and tenant including dilapidations claims, business tenancy renewals, enfranchisement, rights of first refusal, RTM, appointment of managers and service charge disputes.

Real property disputes including mortgage related claims and in particular LPA receivers, property related professional negligence, co-ownership, easements, nuisance, restrictive covenants, boundary disputes and Party Wall Act matters.

As well as appearing frequently in the County Court and the High Court, Carl has represented clients in the First-Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) and the Court of Appeal.

"Very bright, gets on well with clients and is a terrier in court" and "he's extremely knowledgeable, doesn't balk at any points and is ready with the answers." Chambers UK Bar Guide 2018 (Real Estate Litigation)

"A hidden treasure; he is very bright, good in court and with clients, and always goes the long mile without being asked."

Legal 500 2017 (Property Litigation)

Contributed to

131

Is a separate lease of a car park considered a ‘dwelling’ for the purposes of section 38 of the Landlord
Is a separate lease of a car park considered a ‘dwelling’ for the purposes of section 38 of the Landlord
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a separate lease of a car park considered a ‘dwelling’ for the purposes of section 38 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, and if the a service charge claim can be dealt with in the First-tier Tribunal.

Is it correct that CRAR under the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 is not enforceable against
Is it correct that CRAR under the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 is not enforceable against
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether CRAR under the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 is not enforceable against the Crown.

Is it possible by agreement (on the grant of a lease) to substitute the compensation provisions in the
Is it possible by agreement (on the grant of a lease) to substitute the compensation provisions in the
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether an agreement (on the grant of a lease) can be made to substitute the compensation provisions in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 with terms that determine the sum payable in a manner agreed (at grant) between the parties.

Is it possible to grant an express easement for a term of years absolute subject to termination
Is it possible to grant an express easement for a term of years absolute subject to termination
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether it is possible to grant an express easement for a term of years absolute subject to termination provisions.

Is it possible to make a single application under CPR 31.17 for pre-action disclosure against two
Is it possible to make a single application under CPR 31.17 for pre-action disclosure against two
Q&A

This Q&A discusses whether a claimant can make a single application under CPR 31.17 for a pre-action disclosure against two parties.

Is there any real substantive difference between the registrar’s and the court’s powers to order
Is there any real substantive difference between the registrar’s and the court’s powers to order
Q&A

This Q&A considers the power to order rectification of a registry as defined in LRA 2002, Sch 4.

Must a property which is let on an assured shorthold tenancy have heating in every room?
Must a property which is let on an assured shorthold tenancy have heating in every room?
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether ASTs in England are required to have heating in every room.

Pursuant to section 23(1) of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, under a new lease, the
Pursuant to section 23(1) of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, under a new lease, the
Q&A

This Q&A considers which party should benefit from a rent arrears payment pursuant to section 23(1) of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995.

Tenant A owns one flat in a block of three flats. The other two flats are owned by Tenant B. Following
Tenant A owns one flat in a block of three flats. The other two flats are owned by Tenant B. Following
Q&A

This Q&A considers how to serve an acceptance notice under section 6 of Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.

There is a three party lease where the right to manage has been exercised. The landlord and tenant have
There is a three party lease where the right to manage has been exercised. The landlord and tenant have
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether a right to manage company has to be a party to a deed or whether it should just be the landlord, tenant and original management company where there is a three party lease, the right to manage has not been exercised, the landlord and tenant have agreed to amend the ground rent provisions and are going to do this by a deed of variation.

There is an ongoing dispute between a landlord and tenant as to the compliance with the tenancy deposit
There is an ongoing dispute between a landlord and tenant as to the compliance with the tenancy deposit
Q&A

This Q&A considers how a tenant can best document that they have vacated the premises on a ‘without prejudice’ basis subject to the landlord not charging rent pending vacation and also considers how it will impact the landlord’s ability to gain possession in any court proceedings.

To what extent can a buyer rely on searches provided by the seller in a commercial property sale?
To what extent can a buyer rely on searches provided by the seller in a commercial property sale?
Q&A

This Q&A considers the extent to which a buyer can rely on searches provided by the seller in a commercial property sale.

Two neighbouring properties (A and B) have mutual rights of way over a shared access which straddles
Two neighbouring properties (A and B) have mutual rights of way over a shared access which straddles
Q&A

This Q&A considers whether the consent of the beneficiary of a ‘no disposition’ restriction is required in relation to a mutual deed of release of easement.

Under the terms of a lease a landlord is obliged to carry out repairs 'subject to payment of the
Under the terms of a lease a landlord is obliged to carry out repairs 'subject to payment of the
Q&A

This Q&A considers under what circumstances tenants can enforce a landlord's obligations when they are subject to payment of service charges, and whether a claim can be brought against another lessee for failure to pay their contribution.

What are the circumstances which will result in a 12-month bar on a tenant re-serving a section 42 notice
What are the circumstances which will result in a 12-month bar on a tenant re-serving a section 42 notice
Q&A

This Q&A considers the circumstances which will result in a 12-month bar on a tenant re-serving a section 42 notice under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993.

What are the implications if the tenants are not informed of a change of landlord?
What are the implications if the tenants are not informed of a change of landlord?
Q&A

This Q&A considers the implications of failing to give tenants notice of a change in landlord under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 and the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.

What are the section 21 notice requirements to determine an assured shorthold tenancy granted in 2013,
What are the section 21 notice requirements to determine an assured shorthold tenancy granted in 2013,
Q&A

This Q&A considers the prescribed form for a section 21 notice under the DA 2015. It is assumed that the property is situated in England and it is not a HMO.

What are you to do with a statutory deposit held as stakeholder pursuant to paragraph 2, Schedule 2 to
What are you to do with a statutory deposit held as stakeholder pursuant to paragraph 2, Schedule 2 to
Q&A

This Q&A considers what to do with a statutory deposit held as stakeholder pursuant to the Leasehold Reform (Collective Enfranchisement and Lease Renewal) Regulations 1993, SI 1993/2407, Sch 2, para 2 when your landlord client disinstructs you.

What constitutes ‘substantial works’ under Ground 6 of section 8 possession proceedings? Would the
What constitutes ‘substantial works’ under Ground 6 of section 8 possession proceedings? Would the
Q&A

This Q&A considers what constitutes ‘substantial works’ under Ground 6 of section 8 possession proceedings.

What happens when a landlord serves a section 25 notice with proposed terms for a new lease but the
What happens when a landlord serves a section 25 notice with proposed terms for a new lease but the
Q&A

This Q&A considers what happens when a tenant fails to respond by the deadline of a section 25 notice with proposed terms for a new lease.

Practice Areas

Panel

  • Q&A Panel

Qualified Year

  • 2001

Membership

  • Property Bar Association
  • Chancery Bar Association

Education

  • MA (Oxon), The Queens College, Oxford

If you expected to see yourself on this page, click here.