Reasons for dismissal ― capability

Produced by Tolley in association with Hannah Freeman at Old Square Chambers
Employment Tax
Guidance

Reasons for dismissal ― capability

Produced by Tolley in association with Hannah Freeman at Old Square Chambers
Employment Tax
Guidance
imgtext

Dismissal for incompetence / poor performance

Dismissal for incompetence (otherwise known as poor performance) is a potentially fair reason for dismissal. As long as the employer has acted reasonably in reaching the decision to dismiss, a tribunal will not interfere with that decision even if they themselves would have reached a different conclusion. The test applied in deciding whether or not a dismissal was fair will be whether the employer genuinely believed, on reasonable grounds, that the employee was incompetent to do their job. It is not necessary for the employer to prove that the employee was in fact incapable or incompetent.

However, the employer will usually be expected to provide evidence that they:

  1. had adequate evidence of incompetence at the time of the decision to dismiss

  2. adopted a fair procedure prior to the decision

  3. considered whether there was suitable alternative work for the employee to do

Evidence of incompetence may come in a number of forms. In some jobs, there may be a clear and objective

Continue reading the full document
To gain access to additional expert tax guidance, workflow tools, generative tax AI, and tax research, register for a free trial of Tolley+™
Hannah Freeman
Hannah Freeman linkedinicon

Barrister at Old Square Chambers , OMB, Employment Tax


Hannah is an experienced employment law specialist advising on all forms of discrimination, maternity and paternity rights, unfair dismissal, contractual disputes, part-time working and TUPE. Hannah acts for claimants and respondents in both the public and private sectors, including the NHS, the police, local authorities, educational institutions, financial services and the hospitality industry, as well as providing training and support to in-house legal and HR teams.

Powered by Tolley+
  • 14 Sep 2022 10:19

Popular Articles

Winding up a trust ― legal, administrative and compliance issues

Winding up a trust ― legal, administrative and compliance issuesOverviewWhen winding up a trust, there are legal formalities and compliance issues that need to be dealt with, as well as IHT and CGT consequences that flow from the termination. This guidance note considers when and how a trust comes

14 Jul 2020 14:01 | Produced by Tolley Read more Read more

Enterprise management incentive schemes

Enterprise management incentive schemesWhat is an enterprise management incentive (EMI) scheme?The enterprise management incentive (EMI) scheme is a tax-advantaged share option employee incentive scheme aimed at small entrepreneurial companies that meet certain conditions. It is designed to assist

14 Jul 2020 11:36 | Produced by Tolley Read more Read more

First year allowances

First year allowancesFirst year allowances (FYAs) are available on the following items:•first-year relief on qualifying new main rate plant and machinery (at 100%, which is described by HMRC as ‘full expensing’) and special rate assets (at 50%) from 1 April 2023 (companies only). These FYAs were

14 Jul 2020 11:41 | Produced by Tolley Read more Read more