I5.333 Commercial transactions and exit charges
If the trustees make a disposition as a result of which the value of relevant property in the settlement is diminished, tax is not charged on the disposition if it is such that the commercial transactions1 (I3.141–I3.148) or grants of agricultural tenancies2 (I3.159) provisions would prevent it from being a transfer of value. For these purposes, the legislation imagines that the trustees are beneficially entitled to the property3.
The burden of showing that this is so is on the trustees.
Apart from any inherent difficulties there may be in applying the commercial transactions rule to dispositions made by an individual, its application to the trustees of settled property (with no QIIP) presents the additional difficulty of deciding whether the assumed beneficial entitlement of the trustees requires any further facts. The discussion which follows is confined to considering the problems which are peculiar to applying the commercial transactions rule to trustees of settled property with no qualifying interest in possession; for the general problems which arise in its application, see I3.141–I3.148.
The first requirement is to show that the disposition was not made in a transaction intended to confer any gratuitous benefit on any person4 (see I3.143). 'Transaction' here includes a series of transactions and any associated operations5 (see I3.145).
The main problems about applying this to trustees of settlements without a QIIP are:
• is it the subjective intention of the trustees (or any other person effecting an associated operation or a transaction belonging to the