Rely on the most comprehensive, up-to-date legal content designed and curated by lawyers for lawyers
Work faster and smarter to improve your drafting productivity without increasing risk
Accelerate the creation and use of high quality and trusted legal documents and forms
Streamline how you manage your legal business with proven tools and processes
Manage risk and compliance in your organisation to reduce your risk profile
Stay up to date and informed with insights from our trusted experts, news and information sources
Access the best content in the industry, effortlessly — confident that your news is trustworthy and up to date.
Find up-to-date guidance on points of law and then easily pull up sources to support your advice with Lexis PSL
Check out our straightforward definitions of common legal terms.
Our trusted tax intelligence solutions, highly-regarded exam training and education materials help guide and tutor Tax professionals
Access our unrivalled global news content, business information and analytics solutions
Insurance, risk and compliance intelligence using big data, proprietary linking and advanced analytics.
A leading provider of software platforms for professional services firms
In-depth analysis, commentary and practical information to help you protect your business
LexisNexis Blogs shed light on topics affecting the legal profession and the issues you're facing
Legal professionals trust us to help navigate change. Find out how we help ensure they exceed expectations
Lex Chat is a LexisNexis current affairs podcast sharing insights on topics for the legal profession
Discuss the latest legal developments, ask questions, and share best practice with other LexisPSL subscribers
What evidence does the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC) take into account when determining whether acts of communication to the public are targeted at the public in the UK?
In Omnibill (Pty) Ltd v Egpsxxx Ltd (in liquidation) and another [2014] EWHC 3762 (IPEC), [2014] All ER (D) 170 (Nov) the claimant company contended that the defendants had infringed its copyright by reproducing its images on the first defendant’s website. The IPEC, in finding for the claimant, held that, on the evidence, the first defendant had been communicating reproductions of the claimant’s artistic works to the public in the UK.
© Tim Parkinson
The main issue for the court to determine was whether the Escortgps website or the relevant parts of it had been targeted at the UK and so were communicating reproductions of the claimant’s artistic works to the public in the UK. If this was the case then the first defendant would be found to have infringed the claimant’s copyright under the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988, s 20 (CDPA 1988).
The court worked on the basis that the servers which hosted the website were not UK based.
In considering the targeting question, the court considered, by analogy, criteria which the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has treated as relevant to targeting in the joined cases C-585/08 and C-144/09 Pammer and another v Reederei Karl Schluter GmbH & Co KG and another [2010] All ER (D) 84 (Dec), as follows:
‘The following matters, the list of which is not exhaustive, are capable of constituting evidence from which it may be concluded that the trader’s activity is directed to the Member State of the consumer’s domicile, namely the international nature of the activity, mention of itineraries from other Member States for going to the place where the trader is established, use of a language or a currency other than the language or currency generally used in the Member State in which the trader is established with the possibility of making and confirming the reservation in that other language, mention of telephone numbers with an international code, outlay of expenditure on an internet referencing service in order to facilitate access to the trader’s site or that of its intermediary by consumers domiciled in other Member States, use of a top-level domain name other than that of the Member State in which the trader is established, and mention of an international clientele composed of customers domiciled in various Member States. It is for the national courts to ascertain whether such evidence exists.’
The court stated that the question of whether a website is targeted at a particular country is a multi-factorial one which depends on all the circumstances. Those circumstances include things which can be inferred from looking at the content on the website itself and elements arising from the nature of the services offered by the website (such as those listed by the CJEU in Pammer). However, the question of targeting is not necessarily decided by looking only at the website, other factors may be taken into account too, such as the number of visitors accessing the website from the UK.
The court also covered the position where only part of a website targets the UK. Many websites are targeted at only one country but where some parts of a website are targeted differently from others, this would be dealt with as a question of fact. The court here referred to its arguments in Thomas Pink v Victoria’s Secret [2014] EWHC 2631 (Ch), [2014] All ER (D) 66 (Aug) which dealt with where pages on Facebook were targeted.
The court found that the first defendant’s Escortgps website and one of its South African sub-domains (the sub domains provided advertisements by individual escorts based in different countries such as South Africa) were communicating reproductions of the claimant’s artistic works to the public in the UK and as a result the first defendant had infringed the claimant’s copyright.
This type of case is largely decided on its facts. However, the judgment summarises some important factors that lawyers should consider on the question of whether in relation to a globally focussed website, targeting has taken place in the UK:
All in all the courts appear to be adopting an increasingly sophisticated and multi-layered approach to targeting that offers increased protection to rights holders.
Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK
* denotes a required field
0330 161 1234