Rely on the most comprehensive, up-to-date legal content designed and curated by lawyers for lawyers
Work faster and smarter to improve your drafting productivity without increasing risk
Accelerate the creation and use of high quality and trusted legal documents and forms
Streamline how you manage your legal business with proven tools and processes
Manage risk and compliance in your organisation to reduce your risk profile
Stay up to date and informed with insights from our trusted experts, news and information sources
Access the best content in the industry, effortlessly — confident that your news is trustworthy and up to date.
Find up-to-date guidance on points of law and then easily pull up sources to support your advice with Lexis PSL
With over 30 practice areas, we have all bases covered. Find out how we can help
Our trusted tax intelligence solutions, highly-regarded exam training and education materials help guide and tutor Tax professionals
Regulatory, business information and analytics solutions that help professionals make better decisions
A leading provider of software platforms for professional services firms
In-depth analysis, commentary and practical information to help you protect your business
LexisNexis Blogs shed light on topics affecting the legal profession and the issues you're facing
Legal professionals trust us to help navigate change. Find out how we help ensure they exceed expectations
Lex Chat is a LexisNexis current affairs podcast sharing insights on topics for the legal profession
Discuss the latest legal developments, ask questions, and share best practice with other LexisPSL subscribers
The liquidators of the claimant company issued proceedings against its directors and third party companies alleging that the defendants had perpetrated a fraudulent conspiracy which had amounted to a breach of fiduciary duty on the part of the directors dishonestly assisted by the other defendants. Two defendant companies applied to strike out the claim against them on the grounds that the company was barred by the principle of ex turpi causa non oritur actio. The High Court dismissed the applications. The Court of Appeal, Civil Division, upheld that decision on the grounds that the fact that the fraudulent director was the directing mind and will of the company had never been regarded as an answer to a claim by the company against the directors for a breach of duty committed against the company.
This is a welcome decision from the Court of Appeal—a victory for common sense and a firm limitation of the effects of the oft quoted case of Stone & Rolls Ltd (in liquidation) v Moore Stephens (a firm)  UKHL 39, 1 All ER (Comm) 125.
The directors of Bilta were pursued by their former company and its liquidators for breach of fiduciary duty and for fraudulent trading.The appellants in this appeal (who were suppliers to Bilta) were pursued for fraudulent trading under the Insolvency Act 1986, s 213 (IA 1986) and for dishonest assistance of the directors’ breach of duty. The liquidators sought compensation of some £38m in relation to a VAT fraud in the trading of carbon credits. The case had many of the common hallmarks of this type of fraud—Bilta never had the money it would have needed to pay the VAT consequent on the trade, it had an offshore bank account etc.
Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK
* denotes a required field
**excludes LexisPSL Practice Compliance, Practice Management and Risk and Compliance. To discuss trialling these LexisPSL services please email customer service via our online form. Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK. We may terminate this trial at any time or decide not to give a trial, for any reason. Trial includes one question to LexisAsk during the length of the trial. See our full terms here.
Access this article and thousands of others like it free by subscribing to our blog.
Read full article
Already a subscriber? Login
Frances gained her LLB (Hons) at Kings’ College, London University in 1983. She then attended Chester College of Law to take what were then the Solicitors’ Final Examinations. She has been at Moon Beever since 1984 where she trained, qualifying in 1986, and a partner since 1988 becoming Managing Partner in 2000. She is also a founder partner of ShawnCoulson, an international association, of which Moon Beever is the London office. She is Head of Insolvency and Business Recovery at Moon Beever running a substantial team of insolvency specialists. She undertakes most areas of personal and corporate insolvency, specialising in contentious insolvency especially cases involving fraud, as well as provisional liquidations and injunctive work generally.
She is Chairman of the Appeal Committee at ACCA and a member of the Insolvency Law Evaluation Panel at the Insolvency Service, and CBI Insolvency Panel as well as a member of Insol, and the IBA and, veering towards the personal, of the NFU, and the Carlton Club.
Frances is a regular speaker in the UK and abroad on insolvency and practice management.
Frances was formerly Chairman of the SPG Committee of R3, the Insolvency trade body representing 97% of licensed insolvency practitioners. She is President of R3 for 2011-2012, and remains a member of its R3 Policy Group.
She is interested in all things equestrian as are her three daughters and her husband, and spends her free time (such as it is) with her family and other animals, riding and trying to improve her strokes at Real Tennis.
0330 161 1234