Rely on the most comprehensive, up-to-date legal content designed and curated by lawyers for lawyers
Work faster and smarter to improve your drafting productivity without increasing risk
Accelerate the creation and use of high quality and trusted legal documents and forms
Streamline how you manage your legal business with proven tools and processes
Manage risk and compliance in your organisation to reduce your risk profile
Stay up to date and informed with insights from our trusted experts, news and information sources
Access the best content in the industry, effortlessly — confident that your news is trustworthy and up to date.
Find up-to-date guidance on points of law and then easily pull up sources to support your advice with Lexis PSL
Check out our straightforward definitions of common legal terms.
Our trusted tax intelligence solutions, highly-regarded exam training and education materials help guide and tutor Tax professionals
Access our unrivalled global news content, business information and analytics solutions
Insurance, risk and compliance intelligence using big data, proprietary linking and advanced analytics.
A leading provider of software platforms for professional services firms
In-depth analysis, commentary and practical information to help you protect your business
LexisNexis Blogs shed light on topics affecting the legal profession and the issues you're facing
Legal professionals trust us to help navigate change. Find out how we help ensure they exceed expectations
Lex Chat is a LexisNexis current affairs podcast sharing insights on topics for the legal profession
Discuss the latest legal developments, ask questions, and share best practice with other LexisPSL subscribers
How has the European Securities and Markets Authority’s (ESMA’s) supervision and regulation of credit rating agencies (CRAs) and trade repositories (TRs) developed and what is its likely future trajectory? Ewa Herman, an expert on European law, examines the future of CRAs and TRs in light if ESMA’s annual report.
On 16 February 2015, ESMA published its annual report and work plan for the direct supervision of CRAs and TRs. The report presents key elements of ESMA’s risk-based supervisory focal points in 2014 followed by the main priorities foreseen for 2015 towards an effective oversight of the supervised entities, improved regulatory standards and efficient risk analysis.
The report provides an overview of ESMA’s activities in 2014 as single supervisor of CRAs according to Regulation (EC) 1060/2009 (the CRA Regulation). In particular it:
In regard to TRs, the report emphasises ESMA’s direct and exclusive supervision accomplishments under Regulation (EU) 648/2012 on OTC derivatives, central counterparties and trade repositories (EMIR).
In the course of 2014, ESMA published relevant draft RTS on three key matters related to CRAs:
On 16 July 2014, ESMA issued a consultation paper on the periodic information to be submitted by CRAs to ESMA in order to ensure their efficient supervision based on high quality, relevant and timely data (see News 16/07/2014 132). After a public hearing on 15 October 2014, and a consultation which closed on 31 October 2014, the new guidelines are scheduled to be published in 2015. Moreover, 2014 reflected ESMA’s interpretation of the prior CRA Regulation amendments—introduced by Regulation (EU) 462/2013—included in the set of Q&As published by ESMA on 17 December 2013.
Based on provisions of EMIR, ESMA conducts the registration, supervision and recognition of TRs. During 2014, the Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 667/2014 supplementing EMIR with regard to rules of procedure for penalties imposed on TRs by ESMA including rules on the right of defence and temporal provisions came into effect. Additionally, ESMA’s data validation guidance was published.
In 2014, the critical oversight challenge manifested itself in several incident notifications within the reporting obligation, which came into effect on 12 February 2014 and resulted in a total of 10 billion received reports. At the beginning of 2015, 300 million trade reports were submitted on a weekly basis by the relevant counterparties and processed by the six registered TRs.
The report sets ESMA’s biannual strategic aims for the CRAs’ supervisory practices. In 2015/16, ESMA will target the minimisation of conflicts of interest in the rating process and promote effective risk management. Consequently, strong governance and controls are set to come under ESMA’s scrutiny. ESMA will also focus on CRAs’ internal decision-making processes, as well as their business development processes, through on-going supervision, individual or thematic reviews or investigations.
In 2015, ESMA signalled an enhanced focus on TRs’ risk profiles, indicating a higher probability of infringement, lack of compliance and contagion effects. ESMA’s future supervisory efforts will be channelled towards tackling a number of issues related to the data quality identified in 2014. Thematic reviews and investigations will be carried out on:
Individual reviews and investigations will be conducted on:
For the first time enforcement actions have been brought against CRAs—in the EU in 2014 and US in 2015. Following an investigation triggered by an erroneous Standard & Poor’s (S&P) Global Credit Portal alert downgrading an unsolicited rating of France, on 3 June 2014, ESMA issued a public notice (in accordance with the CRA Regualtion, arts 23e(5) and 24). The notice reported the Board of Supervisors’ finding that the registered CRAs’, S&P’s Credit Market Services France SAS and S&P’s Credit Market Services Europe Limited, had committed the infringements listed in the CRA Regulation, Annex III.I, paras 12, 18. ESMA did not impose a fine. Several months later, on 21 January 2015, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced a series of federal securities law violations by S&P’s Ratings Services involving fraudulent misconduct in its ratings of certain commercial mortgage-backed securities resulting in a settlement exceeding $58m to settle the SEC’s charges in addition to $19m to settle parallel cases announced by the New York Attorney General ($12m) and the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office ($7m). ESMA is cooperating with the SEC in the supervisory colleges established for the three largest CRAs operating internationally—S&P, Fitch Ratings and Moody’s Investor Service.
Furthermore, it remains to be seen to what extent the CRA industry will be impacted in the future by ESMA’s current involvement in various projects of the Joint Committee of the European Supervisory Authorities (ESMA, the European Banking Authority and European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority).
Finally, ESMA’s report reveals a build-up of numerous notified TR exposures (eg disclosure of confidential information to non-authorised parties, service unavailability for market participants and/or supervisors, and a number of technical shortfalls implicating fundamental architecture inaccuracies) affecting the quality and confidentiality of the exchanged TR data, which might require taking further supervisory measures to improve TRs’ performance.
Ewa Herman has over 10 years of professional experience as a lawyer and in-house counsel gained in Germany, Poland and Spain. After graduating in law with specialisation in European and International Law from the European University Viadrina in Frankfurt (Oder), she completed the First and the Second Legal State Examinations in Berlin. Her legal clerkship at the Superior Court of Justice (Kammergericht) in Berlin included placements at the EMU, ECB, Euro Group and ECOFIN Division of the European Directorate of the German Federal Ministry of Finance and at the Representation of the European Commission in Berlin with a focus on financial reform and crisis resolution strategies at European Union, G20 states and EU-member states levels.
Interviewed by Barbara Bergin.
The views expressed by our Legal Analysis interviewees are not necessarily those of the proprietor.
Free trials are only available to individuals based in the UK
* denotes a required field
Emma is head of the Banking and Finance team and the Finance Group at LexisNexis®UK.
Emma has wide-ranging experience in derivatives and capital markets with a particular emphasis on credit derivatives and structured products. Emma qualified as a solicitor with Allen & Overy LLP, working in the derivatives and structured finance teams in both their London and Paris offices before gaining experience with Deutsche Bank AG (advising the foreign exchange prime brokerage desk) and Crédit Agricole CIB (advising the fixed income and derivatives desk) before joining LexisNexis®.
0330 161 1234